Chronic Thanksgiving host refuses to have guests over after they criticized her cooking last year: ‘If someone is going to critique a free meal I spent two days cooking, I shouldn’t be obligated to do it again’

Advertisement
  • Family enjoying Thanksgiving dinner
  • AIO for refusing to host Thanksgiving this year after my sister-in-law criticized my cooking last year?

    I (40F) have hosted Thanksgiving at my house for the last six years.
  • Anyone who hosts knows how much time, money, and stress goes into prepping a full dinner for 14 people, especially while working full-time.
    via Royal-Way8680
  • Last year, my brother's wife (38F) spent half the evening making subtle comments about the food.
    via Royal-Way8680
  • She mentioned that the turkey was "a little dry compared to her mom's," asked if the mashed potatoes were from a box (they weren't), and loudly
    via Royal-Way8680
  • told everyone she was saving room for dessert because she "didn't fill up on the sides." I bit my
    via Royal-Way8680
  • tongue at the time to keep the peace for my brother's sake.
    via Royal-Way8680
  • With the holidays coming up next week, the family group chat started asking what time everyone should arrive at my place. I replied
    via Royal-Way8680
  • politely and said I'm taking a break from hosting this year, and suggested we either do a potluck at someone else's house or go out to a restaurant.
    via Royal-Way8680
  • My brother called me privately and said I'm being petty and holding onto a year-old grudge over "harmless comments," and
    via Royal-Way8680
  • Girl carving Thanksgiving turkey, surrounded by her parents
  • that I'm ruining a family tradition because I can't take a little feedback. My
    via Royal-Way8680
  • mom also thinks I should just let it go and host like usual.
    via Royal-Way8680
  • I feel like if someone is going to critique a free meal I spent two days cooking, I shouldn't be obligated to do it again. Am I overreacting by stepping back from hosting?
    via Royal-Way8680
  • 8kijcj Did you say you were not hosting due to people not appreciating it or did your brother come up with that on his own? Anyway NOR.
    via 8kijcj
  • SiroccoDream LOL Mom and Bro are whining about you being the bigger person because neither of them want to host!
    via SiroccoDream
  • Funny how neither of them told SIL to pipe down last year!
    via SiroccoDream
  • You're right to step back from hosting. If your family doesn't figure out a Plan B, then stay home and enjoy a quiet holiday, or invite friends over instead.
    via SiroccoDream
  • Spare_Flamingo8605 I think you should tell the family group chat that it's your brother and his wife's turn to host.
    via Spare_Flamingo8605
  • Family having a conversation at Thanksgiving dinner
  • 6poundpuppy You should suggest in group chat that your brother and SIL should host, especially since SIL has so many suggestions to offer.
    via 6poundpuppy
  • Or..... Maybe a rotating schedule for all attendees should be implemented. Definitely stand your ground this year and refuse.
    via 6poundpuppy
  • kberson Regardless of what was said and by who, you're not a prisoner to your kitchen. After six years, you're entitled to have one off and let someone else do the cooking.
    via kberson
  • Cinderella2360 I have learned that when someone complains about something, especially in public, you loudly and immediately say "Oh, thank you so much!!! I have been wanting someone else to take this over!!! It's so much work!!!" That shuts down complaints REALLY fast!!!
    via Cinderella2360
  • Man hosting dinner party

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article